Hi,
I wouldn't leave your decision solely to reviews on TripAdvisor. The people that tend to rate using these sights have ever overwhelmingly positive or negative experiences and does not necessarily represent the hotel accurately.Hotel Pinija in Petcrane is 4 star and looks superb.
Mark
I had thought of this one and looked on Trip Advisor. It doesnt always follow like people have said here that their reviews are reflective. I do use Trip Advisor a lot and always try to put a very subjective review for each place I have visited. Some of the things people DO complain about is ridiculous.
I'm still very undecided on what to book for this year and may save this one for next year. Half of my heart is telling me to go back to Cilento as I enjoyed the first time so much!!