Hi Carolyn
This was my 1st trip with JY in May 2017 and it was a superb holiday. Make sure you do all the excursion although it is a fairly busy trip it is at a fairly relaxed pace and you have plenty of time to see everything. The Agrigento tour is certainly a must see. Mount Etna is a experience worth doing as well although when we went we got caught up in the 'Giro Italia' (Cycle race) which made for an interesting afternoon and 4 hours in an excellent service station with a bar while we waited for the roads to reopen to get back to our Hotel.
Unfortunately I can't comment on the Hotels as I see on the website they have changed from the ones we stayed at. The change to Hotel Nettuno in Catania looks like an absolutely fabulous hotel (Trip advisor) We stayed in Antares hotel in Letojanni which was good but a lot of steps and lift etc to get down to the beach and coach. I am surprised that JY has changed from Acacia Resort hotel which was a superb hotel to a choice of 2 Hotels in the centre of Palermo.
Maybe Vickie can explain their reasoning for that had the trip not been half board I can see that restaurants would be required and the Acacia was out on its own. Maybe JY are considering dropping some of the evening meals for future trips.
Website map still showing original Hotel locations.
Take the plunge and go for it you certainly won't regret it and you will meet a excellent group of fellow travellers and you will be looking at booking your next one when you return.
I have also done Highlights of Tuscany (May 18) and Calabria (May 19) and probably Cilento Coast or Puglia (May 20) see I told you it was addictive.
Enjoy your travels.
Paul