I would like to see most of these islands. But I am not a beach person, and don't particularly like being 'trapped' on a cruise either with the so called 'on board entertainment' So I am viewing these as individual destinations rather than a tour of a few of them. Jamaica and Dominican Republic certainly fall under this category like Cuba and the Bahamas.
Aruba and Curacao could be fitted into one tour, but they are too far away for me to be included in a tour with say all the others. Trinidad and Tobago is another.
As for the vote I went for my top three - Jamaica would the most culturally intriguing, followed by Trinidad and Tobago. My third choice went to Antigua for a nice relaxing beach escape to go along with already existing Barbados and St Lucia trips.
Others not mentioned in the vote - St Vincent, the Bahamas, Cayman Islands, Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico, Bermuda, Anguilla, Turks and Caicos, Guadeloupe and Martinique are more places I could not mind visiting.
The list grows long.